TUC criticises long hours culture

Print E-mail
Management - News
Tuesday, 27 November 2007

Long hours working is on the increase in the UK, reversing the slow but steady ten-year decline in people working more than 48 hours a week, according to a new TUC analysis. 

More than one in eight of the workforce now work more than 48 hours each week, with as many as one in six in London putting in 48 hours plus a week.

The law protects people against an average working week of more than 48 hours unless they opt out of working time rules. The TUC says, however, that a lack of enforcement means that ‘bad employers’ know that this is one employment right that they can breach with little or no risk of any consequences.

Presenteeism 

Many employees and business owners may be working longer hours by choice without a boss holding a stick over their heads. They may need their paid overtime to keep up with credit card debts and mortgage payments.

They may suffer from so-called ‘presenteeism’, the self-inflicted obsession to spend more time in the office than your colleagues – even when you are suffering from flu or worse - because you believe that you may otherwise be passed over for bonuses and promotions.

The unions, however, insist that the figures show that a hard core of ‘bad employers’ are taking no notice of either the law or calls from government, progressive employers and unions. By contrast, ‘good employers’ have responded to concerns about the need for a greater work-life balance.

The report simply distinguishes between employers and workers and gives no specifics of industries, types of jobs, size of organisation or salary groups. In its simplified ‘good employer’ versus ‘bad employer’ lingo, it does not give details of the hours worked by owner/managers either.

Regional differences 

The latest Labour Force Survey shows that 93,000 more people now work more than 48 hours a week, taking the total to almost three and a quarter million (3,242,000). This is a rise to 13.1 per cent of the workforce, up from 12.8 per cent last year.

The biggest increases in the numbers of people working in excess of 48 hours are in the South East, where there is an increase of 28,000 to 525,000. London saw an increase of 25,000 to 481,000. These two regions have the highest proportion of the workforce working long hours, respectively 16.1 per cent in London and 14.8 per cent in the South East.

The biggest increase in the share of the workforce putting in more than 48 hours took place in Wales where it went up 1.3 per cent to 12.2 per cent. Only the South West and the East Midlands buck the trend with a small fall in long hours workers.

'Undoudted' abuse

TUC General Secretary Brendan Barber said, "These are very disturbing numbers. They suggest that the slow, but at least steady, decline in those working more than 48 hours a week has come to an end. Many employers recognise that overworked staff are unproductive by introducing more flexibility and better work-life balance, often under union pressure.”

“It now looks as if their efforts are being undone by those who don't care about long hours. No-one should forget that 48 hours is six eight-hour days - more than enough for anyone every week,” Barber added.

He added that there is ‘undoubted’ abuse of the law, but said that employers know they can get away with it because it is rarely enforced. Neither the Health and Safety Executive nor local authorities who share responsibility for enforcement have the resources to implement the law.

Barber claims that the Government knows that employers can abuse the opt-out as ministers consulted on ways to close loopholes in 2004, but have yet to bring forward any concrete proposals for change.

Voluntary opt-out 

The TUC is convinced that the current discussions on how best to protect vulnerable workers and enforce existing rights must include working time rights and closing the loopholes that make a voluntary opt-out a joke in the eyes of the unions.

Under Europe's working time regulations workers are protected from working more than an average 48-hour week. In the UK - unlike other EU countries - all workers can opt out of this protection.

Previous TUC research claimed that this is widely abused - two-thirds are not asked to opt out before they are expected to work in excess of 48 hours and a quarter of those who signed were given no real choice about opting out.

The TUC says that these official figures underestimate long hours working as the sample on which the survey is based is unlikely to include a proper share of migrant workers and excludes those who live at their place of work, such as some hotel and care staff who work long hours.

The report makes no mention of freelancers and the millions of employees who have achieved a better work-life balance after their employers made it possible for them to work remotely, from home. It does not take into account either the shift in working patterns, which has caused the distinction between work and private to become increasingly blurred.

Related links

Share this: Digg It! digg   Post to del.icio.us del.ico.us   Seed in Newsvine Newsvine   Post to reddit Reddit   Post to Furl Furl   Post to Technorati technorati   Facebook
Comments (0)Add Comment

Post a comment
quote
bold
italicize
underline
strike
url
image
quote
quote
By posting on this website you are agreeing to abide by our website comment policy and all posts are subject to the approval of the website editor. We will remove posts that contain offensive or threatening language, personal attacks on the writer or other posters, posts that are off topic and posts that are considered spam or specifically used to promote any commercial products or services. Any poster who repeatedly contravenes the policy will be banned from posting on the website.

busy